Talk:Definitive Tally Hall Video List

• Use the forum thread to sort through and find new videos that were mentioned but never added to the list. -- Also, the original list had links to the videos. We can do this, but it's unfortunate those links may die out (as most of the original ones have already). If you have the time and motivation, be my guest. I suggest adding a link to the video at the end of the title (eg. * Break It Down - Watch) ~ Coz 18:27, 18 January 2010 (UTC)
  • Also, perhaps we should group the Sargasm movies together? Thoughts on this? Or maybe separate all the non-tally hall videos, including The Other Way? --~ Coz 17:29, 18 January 2010 (UTC)

• JILL SAYS: rr.... i've never added to a wiki discussion page before... i hope i'm doing this right.
  • i agree with the suggestion of grouping the sargasm videos together.
  • perhaps linkage is futile cause like you said, the links often expire. :/
  • THIS already has a page so perhaps there should be a section that says "THIS videos" "(see THIS page)"

• Hi Jill. Hope you dont mind I edited yours for aesthetic consistency. Just put an asterisk in the front to help separate each other. At the end of your post, click the appropriate button at the top of this box (2nd from right) to add your signature and timestamp. If youre signed in, it'll know who you are. You can customize your own signature using the Preferences link in the top-right menu of the wiki (if you're signed in). I also agree with you about the THIS section. I personally don't think we need a THIS Singles section, however, if others do, thats fine by me. --~ Coz 18:27, 18 January 2010 (UTC)

• Whats the difference between news and journals? Can they just be combined?
  • Perhaps they can be combined to be News/Journals. The difference is, some videos were posted as the news update. Journal videos were vids included in the journal updates. They were 2 distinct areas of the site, but there's not a whole lot of reason for a particular video to be posted as news or journal, therefore, we can combine them if necessary. Perhaps we should include small descriptions under each header explaining why these are organized the way they are. (eg: Joerilla videos focus solely on the Joerilla character. News/journals are videos posted within news or journal entries.--~ Coz 05:34, 19 January 2010 (UTC)
    • Well i added some stuff in the Journals area, is it placed correctly? ~mike
      • I dont know if its right or wrong, but it works - for now, at least. it can always be changed if someone brings up good reason. But maybe the Boralogues should be on their own. Or perhaps, in an effort to not have redundant info, Boralogues and THIS would get their own headings here, but only have a link to their respective pages in the aforementioned description area below the header. Perhaps I will do that right now! --~ Coz 14:43, 19 January 2010 (UTC)

• Should we add edu/toy orchestra, joe hawley joe hawley, and Cojum Dip videos, or is there a better place for some of those?
  • Frankly, the Tally Hallmanac was made for no other projects except that which Tally Hall put their name on, though that was never a rule. Obviously people have been using it as a place to document side projects and while that's fine, because it's whatever the people want it to be, I personally look at all non-Tally Hall projects as unnecessary for inclusion into the Tally Hallmanac. But... like anything else, if you feel it's worth documenting those other projects, I won't stop you. :) --Coz (talk) 21:11, 14 May 2018 (PDT)
  • Oh boy, that's gonna be a lot of work.