The following are cover songs that Tally Hall and its members have played at concerts or otherwise covered.

Played Live

All Together Now (by The Beatles)
Baby Got Back (by Sir Mix-A-Lot)
Because (by The Beatles)
Blackbird (by The Beatles)
Blinded By The Light (by Manfred Mann's Earth Band)
Bolero (by Maurice Ravel, covered in South by Southwest 2007 (T.H.I.S. Episode))
Cecilia (by Simon and Garfunkel)
Down By The Bay (by Raffi)
Everyday (by Buddy Holly)
Free Bird (by Lynyrd Skynyrd)
Gonna Fly Now (by DeEtta Little)
Happy Together (by The Turtles)
Jump (by Van Halen)
La Bamba (by Ritchie Valens)
Lady Madonna (by The Beatles)
Life in a Cube (by Casey Shea, with Casey Shea)
Maple Leaf Rag (by Scott Joplin)
Praise You (by Fatboy Slim)
Pure Imagination (from Willy Wonka)
Space Oddity (by David Bowie)
Stand By Me (by Ben E. King)
The Continuing Story of Bungalow Bill (by The Beatles)
To Be with You (by Mr. Big)
Who Loves The Sun (by The Velvet Underground)
Why Don't We Do It In The Road? (by The Beatles)

Recorded

Candle on the Water (by Al Kasha and Joel Hirschhorn) feat. Laurel Stucky and Robert Chesnick
Club Can't Handle Me (by Flo Rida) feat. Casey Shea
Just A Friend (by Biz Markie)
Since I don't have you (by The Skyliners)
Smile Like You Mean It (by The Killers)
The Minstrel Boy (by Thomas Moore)
The Rainbow Connection (by Paul Williams and Kenneth Ascher)
White Rabbit (by Jefferson Airplane, with Grace Slick)
Why Bother? (by Rivers Cuomo)
Sleigh Ride Invincibility Star (originally "Sleigh Ride", by The Ronettes)