Here is a list of all the official merchandise sold by Tally Hall over the years. Currently, the only official Tally Hall merchandise store only stocks two items, so for others eBay is recommended. If you are looking to buy a shirt, check to see if the one you're buying was produced by the company listed under the shirt below.

Music

 
Party Boobytrap EP CD
Manufactured 2003, not mass produced
 
Welcome To Tally Hall EP CD
Manufactured 2004, not mass produced
 
Complete Demos CD
Manufactured 2004
 
Pingry EP CD
Manufactured 2005
 
Residency Tour CD
Manufactured 2006, for promotional use
 
Marvin's Marvelous Mechanical Museum CD/LP
Manufactured 2008, 2021-present
 
Welcome To Tally Hall CD
Manufactured 2008, single
 
Good & Evil CD/LP
Manufactured 2011, 2022-present
 
Just a Friend EP
Manufactured 2021-present

Solo/Side Project Music

 
Sketches Cassette
Manufactured 2012, not mass produced
 
Hawaii: Part II CD
Manufactured 2015, 99 copies produced
 
Hawaii: Part II LP
Manufactured 2018, 2020, 2022, not mass produced
 
Variations On A Cloud EP
Manufactured 2019,2023. 2019 edition came with a hat, whereas the 2023 repress didn't.
 
Sketches 3D CD/LP
Manufactured 2019, signed

Clothing

 
Chinchilla
Manufactured 2004-2005
(Tally Hall colors)
 
"Anti-Tally"
Manufactured 2004 (?)
Produced by Fruit of the Loom
 
Banana Man
Manufactured 2005
 
Don't Not Listen
Manufactured 2005-2007(?)
(various colors)
 
Shirt Shirt
Originally Manufactured 2005-2007
Reissued 2022 and is for sale "INDEFINITELY"
(various colors)
Original Producer: UNKNOWN
Current Producer: Ann Arbor Tees / Bella+Canvas
 
Hall Monitor Shirt
Manufactured 2006
 
2006 West Coast World Tour
Manufactured 2006
Produced by American Apparel
 
Toot!
Manufactured 2006-2007
 
Teacup
Manufactured 2007(?)
 
Dino
Manufactured 2008-2009(?)
Produced by American Apparel
 
No Evil
Manufactured 2008-2010
Produced by American Apparel
 
Marvin's (brownish/green)
Manufactured 2008-2010
Produced by American Apparel
 
Royal Blue/Black
Manufactured 2009-2010
 
Heart Attack
Manufactured 2009(?)-2011
 
Good & Evil
Manufactured 2011
 
Tally Hall Good & Evil Tour Shirt
Manufactured 2011
Produced by American Apparel
 
Food Court
Manufactured 2011
 
Marvin's Marvelous Mechanical Museum Limited Edition printing
Manufactured 2017

Side/Solo Project Clothing

 
"Not Rob Cantor" Shirt
Manufactured 2014
 
Rotary Park Shirt
Manufactured 2016
Produced by American Apparel
 
Joe Hawley Joe Hawley Shoes
Manufactured 2016
 
edu Shirt
Manufactured 2019, sketches 3D Kickstarter backer award.
Produced by Bella+Canvas

Side/Solo Project Items

 
"Rob Fight" Poster
Manufactured 2014, 50 copies were made and signed, 20"x 30".
 
Joe Hawley Joe Hawley Lyrics Book
Manufactured 2016, some came signed by Joe, "A lyrics and information book exclusive to Pledge regarding the forthcoming free Joe Hawley Joe Hawley digital album download."
 
Joe Hawley Joe Hawley Clock
Manufactured 2016, "Joe Hawley’s cartoon’d countenance will assist you in your endeavor* to observe mechanical hands."
 
Joe Hawley Ultimate Frisbee
Manufactured 2016, "An Ultimate Frisbee (9&5/8") constructed of recycled plastic."
 
"Sic Semper Joe Hawley" Mug
Manufactured 2016, "Drink your Joe dead language-style."
 
“Sic Semper Joe Hawley” Kazoo
Manufactured 2016, "Because why the fuss not?"

Miscellaneous

 
Tally Hall Logo Keyring
Manufactured 2011-2013?
 
Marvin's Marvelous Mechanical Museum Placemat
Manufactured 2008
 
Tally Hall Picture Poster
Manufactured 2011-2013?
 
Good and Evil Tour Poster
Manufactured 2011-2013?

Stickers

 
Tally Hall Sticker Sticker
Manufactured 2005-2010, 2021-present
The size of this sticker has changed once or twice. The sticker has also been included in Needlejuice Records pre-orders for the 2021-present repressing of MMMM.
 
Place Tally Hall Sticker Here Sticker
Manufactured 2005-2010, 2021-present
The size of this sticker has changed once or twice. The sticker has also been included in Needlejuice Records pre-orders for the 2021-present repressing of MMMM.
 
Royal
Manufactured 2009-2010
(Available in black and white)

Vending Machine Prizes

 
Bora Tattoo
 
Heart Tattoo
 
Logo Tattoo
 
Royal Logo Tattoo
 
Forehead Tattoo
 
Skull Tattoo

Good & Evil Preorder Bonus

Along with the below items, each pre-order package came with a random selection of Tally Hall tattoos and a random photo used in the "Welcome to Tally Hall" music video.

 
Club Largo Table Placard
 
MMMM Fortune (Front)
 
MMMM Fortune (Back)