The following are cover songs that Tally Hall have played at concerts.
Played Live
- All Together Now (by The Beatles)
- Baby Got Back (by Sir Mix-A-Lot)
- Because (by The Beatles)
- Blackbird (by The Beatles)
- Blinded By The Light (by Manfred Mann's Earth Band)
- Bolero (by Maurice Ravel)
- Cecilia (by Simon and Garfunkel)
- Down By The Bay (by Raffi)
- Everyday (by Buddy Holly)
- Free Bird (by Lynyrd Skynyrd)
- Gonna Fly Now (by DeEtta Little)
- Happy Together (by The Turtles)
- Jump (by Van Halen)
- La Bamba (by Ritchie Valens)
- Life in a Cube (by Casey Shea, with Casey Shea)
- Maple Leaf Rag (by Scott Joplin)
- Praise You (by Fatboy Slim)
- Pure Imagination (from Willy Wonka)
- Since I Don't Have You (by The Skyliners)
- Sleigh Ride (by The Ronettes)
- Space Oddity (by David Bowie)
- Stand By Me (by Ben E. King)
- The Continuing Story of Bungalow Bill (by The Beatles)
- To Be with You (by Mr. Big)
- White Rabbit (by Jefferson Airplane)
- Who Loves The Sun (by The Velvet Underground)
- Why Don't We Do It In The Road? (by The Beatles)
Recorded
- Smile Like You Mean It (by The Killers)
- Just A Friend (by Biz Markie)
- Club Can't Handle Me (by Flo Rida) feat. Casey Shea
- Why Bother? (by Rivers Cuomo)